Comments on: To What Degree has Coaching Grown Out of Psychotherapy? http://coachingcommons.org/guest-contributors/to-what-degree-has-coaching-grown-out-of-psychotherapy/ Where Radical Possibilities are Explored & Pursued Sun, 10 Apr 2011 11:20:56 +0000 hourly 1 http://wordpress.org/?v=3.2.1 By: Carol Braddick http://coachingcommons.org/guest-contributors/to-what-degree-has-coaching-grown-out-of-psychotherapy/comment-page-1/#comment-319 Carol Braddick Tue, 25 Mar 2008 19:57:24 +0000 http://www.coachingcommons.org/guest-contributors/to-what-degree-has-coaching-grown-out-of-psychotherapy/#comment-319 Good recall,J! Yes, it was referred to as a fuzzy space which he thought coaching psychology would sit well in. Which of course raises the question of what is coaching psychology? Good recall,J! Yes, it was referred to as a fuzzy space which he thought coaching psychology would sit well in. Which of course raises the question of what is coaching psychology?

]]> By: jsibley http://coachingcommons.org/guest-contributors/to-what-degree-has-coaching-grown-out-of-psychotherapy/comment-page-1/#comment-317 jsibley Mon, 24 Mar 2008 14:59:09 +0000 http://www.coachingcommons.org/guest-contributors/to-what-degree-has-coaching-grown-out-of-psychotherapy/#comment-317 Hi Carol, As I remember it, one of the things Ernesto spoke about was a student's thesis about "the fuzzy space between coaching and therapy." Wasn't he suggesting that we accept that the boundaries are often not that clear? Hi Carol,

As I remember it, one of the things Ernesto spoke about was a student’s thesis about “the fuzzy space between coaching and therapy.” Wasn’t he suggesting that we accept that the boundaries are often not that clear?

]]> By: Carol Braddick http://coachingcommons.org/guest-contributors/to-what-degree-has-coaching-grown-out-of-psychotherapy/comment-page-1/#comment-315 Carol Braddick Sun, 23 Mar 2008 15:41:57 +0000 http://www.coachingcommons.org/guest-contributors/to-what-degree-has-coaching-grown-out-of-psychotherapy/#comment-315 Ernesto Spinelli discussed the linkages and distinction between the 2 fields at the Dec BPS conference. He did the topic such justice - in such a rich and simple way - that I am tempted to hunt down my notes. Absent those, I see it that exec coaching grew out of the need for people to find more effective ways of working. Once exec coaching took hold, coaches began working on all manner of client issues beyond work, and now in specialized niches. Coaching now is a common solution for personal development outside of work. But the focus on personal development may not lead us back to psychotherapy or any particular school of thought in psychotherapy unless the training of the practitioners leans this way. Look forward to others' thoughts Ernesto Spinelli discussed the linkages and distinction between the 2 fields at the Dec BPS conference. He did the topic such justice – in such a rich and simple way – that I am tempted to hunt down my notes.
Absent those, I see it that exec coaching grew out of the need for people to find more effective ways of working. Once exec coaching took hold, coaches began working on all manner of client issues beyond work, and now in specialized niches. Coaching now is a common solution for personal development outside of work. But the focus on personal development may not lead us back to psychotherapy or any particular school of thought in psychotherapy unless the training of the practitioners leans this way. Look forward to others’ thoughts

]]> By: To What Degree has Coaching Grown Out of Psychotherapy? « Econom‚àö‚â†a, management y coaching http://coachingcommons.org/guest-contributors/to-what-degree-has-coaching-grown-out-of-psychotherapy/comment-page-1/#comment-247 To What Degree has Coaching Grown Out of Psychotherapy? « Econom‚àö‚â†a, management y coaching Thu, 06 Mar 2008 22:43:34 +0000 http://www.coachingcommons.org/guest-contributors/to-what-degree-has-coaching-grown-out-of-psychotherapy/#comment-247 [...] of Psychotherapy? Publicado el Marzo 6, 2008 por Leonardo Esteban Ravier Comentario a ‚Äö√Ñ√∫To What Degree has Coaching Grown Out of Psychotherapy?‚Äö√Ñ√π, de Jonathan Sibley The Coaching [...] [...] of Psychotherapy? Publicado el Marzo 6, 2008 por Leonardo Esteban Ravier Comentario a ‚Äö√Ñ√∫To What Degree has Coaching Grown Out of Psychotherapy?‚Äö√Ñ√π, de Jonathan Sibley The Coaching [...]

]]> By: Leonardo Ravier http://coachingcommons.org/guest-contributors/to-what-degree-has-coaching-grown-out-of-psychotherapy/comment-page-1/#comment-240 Leonardo Ravier Thu, 06 Mar 2008 09:37:20 +0000 http://www.coachingcommons.org/guest-contributors/to-what-degree-has-coaching-grown-out-of-psychotherapy/#comment-240 Jonathan, The link (http://www.brief-therapy.org/steve_miracle.htm) doesn´t work . I think that the success of coaching, is based on its alternative proposal to psychology or psychotherapy. If we can not separate from its, the coaching will lose specific weight and will end disappearing or changing (mutated) into "something else", another discipline. The proposal is to discover and describe what is the essence of coaching, what is the unique and special proposal helping people, and then, develop the discipline on that essence. The interaction with other disciplines is good but not sufficient for the foundation of coaching. ------------------------------------------ Spanish version Jonathan, El vínculo(http://www.brief-therapy.org/steve_miracle.htm) no funciona. Creo que el éxito del coaching radica en la alternativa que presenta frente a la psicología o psicoterapia. Si no conseguimos separarla de éstas, perderá peso específico y terminará desapareciendo o cambiando (mutando) en otra "cosa", otra disciplina. La propuesta es descubrir y describir cuál es la esencia del coaching, cuál es su propuesta única y especial para ayudar a las personas, y luego, desarrollarla en base a dicha esencia. La interacción con otras disciplinas es buena pero no suficiente para la fundación del coaching. Jonathan,

The link (http://www.brief-therapy.org/steve_miracle.htm) doesn´t work .

I think that the success of coaching, is based on its alternative proposal to psychology or psychotherapy. If we can not separate from its, the coaching will lose specific weight and will end disappearing or changing (mutated) into “something else”, another discipline.

The proposal is to discover and describe what is the essence of coaching, what is the unique and special proposal helping people, and then, develop the discipline on that essence. The interaction with other disciplines is good but not sufficient for the foundation of coaching.

——————————————

Spanish version

Jonathan,

El vínculo(http://www.brief-therapy.org/steve_miracle.htm) no funciona.

Creo que el ‚àö¬©xito del coaching radica en la alternativa que presenta frente a la psicolog‚àö‚â†a o psicoterapia. Si no conseguimos separarla de ‚àö¬©stas, perder‚àö¬∞ peso espec‚àö‚â†fico y terminar‚àö¬∞ desapareciendo o cambiando (mutando) en otra “cosa”, otra disciplina.

La propuesta es descubrir y describir cuál es la esencia del coaching, cuál es su propuesta única y especial para ayudar a las personas, y luego, desarrollarla en base a dicha esencia. La interacción con otras disciplinas es buena pero no suficiente para la fundación del coaching.

]]>